Repository navigation
Description
Context
AUTH-0025 identifies a versioned authority, FastLED Reciprocal License 1.0-rc1, but its declared source and citation point to mutable blob/main/LICENSE. The research workflow requires exact license version and version history before applying a comparison.
A future edit to main can therefore cause an AI to attribute changed language to rc1 without changing AUTH-0025, its verification date, or PR-0002. This is a provenance defect even though FastLED is only a comparison target in the license-agnostic corpus.
Proposal
Pin AUTH-0025 to an immutable repository commit, release, or tag and record a content hash. State separately whether the local LICENSE represents the current working draft or the historical rc1 snapshot. Define a rule that every versioned project-local license authority uses immutable content and receives a new card for a material revision.
Acceptance criteria
- AUTH-0025's primary source resolves to immutable rc1 content rather than
mainormaster. - The card records the commit/tag/release identifier and a content hash or equivalent immutable artifact identity.
- The card distinguishes historical rc1 text from the repository's current working
LICENSEstate. - A repository check rejects mutable branch URLs for versioned project-local license cards.
- The workflow states when a material license revision requires a new AUTH identifier rather than overwriting an old card.
- PR-0002 is checked against the pinned artifact and remains
legal_review: pending.
Decisions
- Confirmed provenance defect, P1. This issue fixes source identity, not the FastLED license.
- Immutable snapshot required for a versioned name. A verification date alone cannot freeze mutable branch content.
- No LICENSE change. Any future draft revision remains separately authorized and attorney-gated.
Open questions
- Should tags/releases or commit permalinks be the canonical snapshot mechanism?
- Should the corpus retain both a
current draftcard and one immutable card per named release candidate?
Related issues
- Parent: audit: adversarially review the paralegal research corpus #19
- Corpus creation: docs: build a license-agnostic copyleft enforcement research corpus #17
- Historical FastLED drafting review: AI legal review — First Sale trigger, remedies, MIT relicensing & AI-agent instructions (Opus cluster) #3
Activity
zackees commentedon Aug 25, 2026
Sol adversarial review - 2026-08-25
Verdict: confirmed but narrower than filed; leave open. AUTH-0025 has a real latent retrieval/provenance defect because its declared primary URL is a symbolic branch URL. I found no present misquotation in PR-0002, no duplicate issue, no resolving PR, and no tag or release. The current artifact is already independently identifiable, so this is not a missing-evidence emergency and the P1 characterization is too strong absent an actual downstream misattribution.
Exact evidence
Scope corrections and loopholes
More precise acceptance criteria
Attorney and retrieval questions
feat: make reciprocal license project agnostic (#28)
zackees commentedon Aug 26, 2026
PR #28 resolves the first three provenance criteria: AUTH-0025 now points to immutable commit 40ee710, records its SHA-256 and Git blob identity, and distinguishes historical rc1 from the current rc2 working text. PR-0002 remains legal_review: pending. Leaving this issue open because the repository-wide mutable-URL validator and the documented rule for allocating a new AUTH identifier still need implementation.