You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
STORY: Add Resilience4j circuit breaker and retry example #65
Assessment: not actionable in current payment bootstrap
Reviewed payment-service at origin/main commit 335b70f (2026-09-05). This story does not have a meaningful production integration point yet, so no Resilience4j dependency, circuit breaker, retry adapter, tests, branch, or PR was created.
Evidence
pom.xml contains Spring MVC, JDBC/Flyway/PostgreSQL, security, Config Client, and test dependencies, but no outbound HTTP client/provider SDK and no Resilience4j dependency.
The service guidance explicitly says provider integration is deferred and must later be isolated behind outbound ports/adapters (AGENTS.md); the README likewise defers provider adapters, Kafka, and saga orchestration (README.md).
Keep #65 open as a Sprint 6 follow-up, but mark it not-ready for implementation in the current bootstrap. First create and merge the separately tracked payment-rail/provider outbound port, contract, and concrete client adapter (with an explicit idempotency/side-effect policy). Then implement #65 at that adapter boundary with bounded retry/circuit-breaker settings, retryable transport failures only, no retry of definitive 4xx/business failures, and focused adapter tests.
No child task was created, so there is no parent relationship to repair; #65 remains assigned to ramioooz and mapped to Sprint 6 - Operational Resilience and Observability.
Related work and merge order
The current payment bootstrap/lifecycle chain is already merged in this order: payment-service PR #1 -> #2 -> #3 -> #4 -> #5 -> #6, followed by SIT/runtime/quality updates #7, #8, and #9 into main. Those provide the current baseline; they do not introduce a provider client.
Future order: provider integration story/adapter first; then #65; then any provider-specific SIT verification or operational runbook. No PR or merge is applicable for #65 from this bootstrap state.
Superseded by the completed API Gateway resilience scope. Circuit breaking and safe retries were delivered in api-gateway#20 and integrated in api-gateway#22; Redis-backed rate limiting was delivered in api-gateway#21. Keeping this generic story open would duplicate the implemented gateway capability. If payment-provider-specific resilience is required later, create a new concrete child under the Sprint 5 payment story with an identified downstream dependency.
Activity
ramioooz commentedon Sep 5, 2026
Assessment: not actionable in current payment bootstrap
Reviewed
payment-serviceatorigin/maincommit335b70f(2026-09-05). This story does not have a meaningful production integration point yet, so no Resilience4j dependency, circuit breaker, retry adapter, tests, branch, or PR was created.Evidence
pom.xmlcontains Spring MVC, JDBC/Flyway/PostgreSQL, security, Config Client, and test dependencies, but no outbound HTTP client/provider SDK and no Resilience4j dependency.PaymentInstructionServicecalls onlyPaymentInstructionRepository. The concrete outbound adapters are persistence adapters, includingPostgresPaymentInstructionRepository; there is no payment-provider call to protect.AGENTS.md); the README likewise defers provider adapters, Kafka, and saga orchestration (README.md)../mvnw --batch-mode --no-transfer-progress test-> 17 tests, 0 failures, build success.Delivery decision
Keep #65 open as a Sprint 6 follow-up, but mark it not-ready for implementation in the current bootstrap. First create and merge the separately tracked payment-rail/provider outbound port, contract, and concrete client adapter (with an explicit idempotency/side-effect policy). Then implement #65 at that adapter boundary with bounded retry/circuit-breaker settings, retryable transport failures only, no retry of definitive 4xx/business failures, and focused adapter tests.
No child task was created, so there is no parent relationship to repair; #65 remains assigned to
ramiooozand mapped toSprint 6 - Operational Resilience and Observability.Related work and merge order
The current payment bootstrap/lifecycle chain is already merged in this order: payment-service PR #1 -> #2 -> #3 -> #4 -> #5 -> #6, followed by SIT/runtime/quality updates #7, #8, and #9 into
main. Those provide the current baseline; they do not introduce a provider client.Future order: provider integration story/adapter first; then #65; then any provider-specific SIT verification or operational runbook. No PR or merge is applicable for #65 from this bootstrap state.
ramioooz commentedon Sep 5, 2026
Superseded by the completed API Gateway resilience scope. Circuit breaking and safe retries were delivered in api-gateway#20 and integrated in api-gateway#22; Redis-backed rate limiting was delivered in api-gateway#21. Keeping this generic story open would duplicate the implemented gateway capability. If payment-provider-specific resilience is required later, create a new concrete child under the Sprint 5 payment story with an identified downstream dependency.