Skip to content

Remaining bare except: / swallowed exceptions in tests/ and src/ (Codacy + hidden failures) #115

Description

@petercorke

Follow-up to #51 / #114, which fixed the bare except: pass pattern in tests/test_image_point_features.py. Inventory of what remains as of 2026-10-03 (main at 770a031). These are likely contributing to the Codacy B grade (Pylint/Pyflakes bare-except and try/except/pass/W0702/W0703-type findings, see #41) and, in tests, hide real failures.

Why it matters

In tests, a bare except: also swallows the AssertionError from assert*, so the test can never fail. Fixing the same pattern in #114 showed that several of those tests had been calling APIs that don't exist (Image.SURF, corners, getpixel, concat), so expect similar findings here: fix by running each snippet unprotected on OpenCV 4 and 5, rewriting against the real API with direct assertions, and mutation-checking that the test now fails when the code is broken (see #114's PR description for the method).

tests/

File bare except: except Exception + pass/continue
tests/test_camera.py 11 8
tests/base/test_base_color.py 3 1
tests/test_ros.py 0 3
tests/conftest.py 0 2 (probably legitimate GUI-suppression; review rather than blanket-remove)

src/

Location Issue Suggested fix
base/color.py:966 and :976 (rgb2xyz-style white/primaries lookup) bare except: around a dict lookup, then raise ValueError("unknown white value, must be one of" ", ".join(...)). Real bug: the two adjacent string literals concatenate first, so ", ".join(...) uses the whole sentence as the separator; the error message is garbled. except KeyError: and build the message with an f-string: f"unknown white value, must be one of {', '.join(_whites)}", plus a test that checks the message
base/findpeaks.py:119 bare except: around Polynomial.fit, then print + continue catch the specific exceptions Polynomial.fit raises for a neighbourhood falling off the data; use warnings.warn rather than print
base/imageio.py:1033 (set_window_title) bare except: pass except (AttributeError, RuntimeError): (backends without a window manager)
Camera.py, ImageProcessing.py, base/imageio.py one except Exception: pass/continue each review each: narrow the exception type or log

Suggested approach

Separate small PRs: (1) color.py message bug + test (src, real fix), (2) other src sites, (3) tests/test_camera.py, (4) tests/base/test_base_color.py and the rest. Add E722 (bare except) and BLE001/S110 (try-except-pass) to the ruff rule set once clean so it can't regress (see the typing/lint cluster, #40/#41).

Related: #41, #51, #113

Activity

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    tech-debtKnown technical debt / deferred cleanup, not a live bug

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions